Stable Value Vs Money Market Update: An Interest Rate Primer

MetLife Retirement & Income Solutions

Stable Value Vs. Money Market Primer

Apr 14, 2022

Inflation in the United States continues at a rate not seen for nearly 40 years: 7% for 2021 according to the U.S. Consumer Price Index report for December, the largest annual increase since 1982.Inflation has significantly decreased real returns for both Stable Value and Money Markets. The chart below compares the growth of $100 invested in stable value and money market for the ten year period ending 12/31/2021, adjusted for inflation. Over the past ten years, investments in Money Market Funds have consistently lost purchasing power, nearly 15% over the period. Stable Value investments have been able to maintain their value in real terms until the recent dramatic COVID-related spike in inflation.2

Accumulated Value in Constant Dollars
Money Market Funds Chart

In terms of direct control, the Fed can only set the Fed Funds Rate. This is the rate that banks charge each other to lend excess reserves overnight. Changes in the Fed Funds Rate have a significant effect on short-term interest rates. The Fed can also influence interest rates at longer points of the yield curve through Open Market Operations or Quantitative Easing. This is when the Fed buys (or sells) Treasuries or other assets in the market. At the January 2022 Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) meeting, held on January 26th, the Fed announced that Quantitative Easing will continue at $30 billion for February, down from a peak of $120 billion a month last November, and is expected to end in March when the Fed Funds Rate is hiked 0.25%.3

So how does this affect today’s yield curve? How do we know what is “priced in” already? In short, already “priced in” depends on expectations about future interest rates. For example, the graph below shows 3-month Treasury Rates for the prior 3 months. The 3-month Treasury yield, being a short-term and extremely low risk asset, would be heavily influenced by a change in the Fed Funds rate. Until late December, the rate had been fairly constant at 5 bps. As inflation and other economic data came in, market participants became more convinced that the Fed would have to raise rates. The yield has risen along with expectations. If the Fed does raise rates in March, the 3-month yield will probably bump up slightly, as the expectation was already near certain. However, if the Fed surprises and doesn’t raise the interest rates, then the 3-month yield would likely immediately drop.  

Money Market Funds Chart

The next graph is of the 10-year Treasury yield. As a long-term rate, the yield reflects expectations of not only the upcoming rate decision, but future ones as well. We can see that predictions of the distant future are far more uncertain and thus much more variable. The rise in rates from early January 2022 was appoximately 40 bps, higher then the anticipated rate increase in March of this year. This reflects the expectation that March will not be the end of the rate hike cycle.  

Money Market Funds Chart

How does this impact Stable Value Fund and Money Market Fund rates? Money
Market Funds invest in the extreme short end of the yield curve. Legally, the weighted averaged maturity of the underlying Money Market Fund assets must be less than 60 days, with no assets having maturities longer than 13 months. Money Market Fund rates are heavily influenced by the change in Fed Funds Rates. As short-term rates rise with the expectations of a rate hike, Money Market Funds can reinvest their maturing assets at higher yields and generate more return.  Since, on average, their assets turn over every two months, the lag time between rates increasing and higher Money Market Fund rates is very short. However, it is important to note that even with the anticipated rise in rates, Money Market Fund yields will remain low by historical standards. Additionally, the last time the Fed raised rates in 2018, Money Market Funds also moved to increase their fees as well, retaining some of the yield gains.

Stable Value Funds, on the other hand, invest in the intermediate part of the yield curve and use an insurance contract known as a “wrap” to provide the guaranteed crediting rate and principal protection. The normal yield curve is upward sloping.  As a result,  investing in longer term assets has inherent return advantages.  However, this also means that the assets do not turnover as quickly and crediting rates react more slowly to yield changes. The Stable Value wrap takes into account the market values of the assets along with current yields to calculate the guaranteed crediting rate. 

When yields rise, existing assets that were issued with a lower yield lose value, which is reflected in their market value. However, this reduced market value is offset by the higher yield and thus the crediting rate stays relatively stable. As assets mature and get reinvested at higher rates, the crediting rate will then rise. Thus, crediting rates for Stable Value Funds as a percentage of the current crediting rate will rise more slowly than Money Market Fund rates.  However, even though the crediting rate will lag for Stable Value Funds, it’s unlikely that Money Market Funds will outperform Stable Value investments.

During times of market uncertainty, many investors might consider it prudent to protect a portion of their assets with Stable Value. Because Stable Value is an investment option in a DC plan with regular ongoing contributions, those contributions get invested at higher yields as rates rise, helping to mitigate the impact of the rate increases on the portfolio and the crediting rate. For DC plan participants, stable Value provides full liquidity, principal protection, and a guaranteed interest rate.

Stable Value Solutions

Keep risk down with a stable value option that steadily rises.

1 https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-01-12/inflation-in-u-s-registers-biggest-annual-gain-since-1982

2 Stable Value numbers represent stable value returns actually credited to participants for MetLife clients who allowed us to use their data. This data may not be representative of returns for the asset class as a whole. Money Market numbers are the weighted gross government rates obtained from sec.gov minus the average expense ratio of large money market providers

3 https://www.cnbc.com/2022/01/26/fed-decision-january-2022-.html

4 CPI Index used is the US CPI Urban Consumers Index from Bloomberg

5 Real return calculated by (1 + Nominal Return)/(1 + CPI) – 1